e-News #64: Massive Buildings Yield Passive Savings
Incorporating Thermal Mass to Save Energy and Improve Thermal Comfort
Incorporating thermal mass into the design of a building is a completely passive way of reducing annual heating and cooling energy use and shifting the summer peak demand to later in the day. In architectural terms, thermal mass refers to the incorporation of solid or liquid materials into the building design to absorb heat or cold and then release it later to moderate building temperature swings. Typical thermal mass elements include concrete, masonry, or stone in a building's walls or floor, or water stored in tanks within the building. Thermal mass can be utilized in a wide variety of facility types, including commercial and residential buildings. And designs can incorporate active strategies such as night flush ventilation to improve the effectiveness of thermal mass elements.
Not only can thermal mass strategies save energy costs, they can also provide improved interior thermal comfort - without requiring additional heating and cooling equipment. This issue of e-News details the benefits of using thermal mass, highlights important design considerations, and provides tips to get the most out of your building's massive elements.
|History of Thermal Mass in Vernacular Architecture|
Thermal mass is not a new technology. In fact, the very earliest human shelters and buildings were constructed with earth-based materials, and such materials can be seen in the vernacular architecture of nearly every region of the world. Construction based on stone, brick, and concrete has been continuously influenced by material availability, technology, and social factors, which include considerations of sustainability.
Likewise, the passive heating and cooling properties of thermal mass are not revolutionary; they have been used for centuries to maintain comfortable living environments.
Traditional adobe houses in Mexico and the Southwest U.S. have thermal mass walls typically constructed of thick sun-dried clay, sand, and straw bricks. Similarly, concrete and stone houses in the Mediterranean and in many other parts of the world continuously moderate indoor air temperatures with little or no input of extra energy.
Thermal mass is an age-old technology that is once again gaining popularity in modern construction, and like many rediscovered technologies, it is taking on new forms in order to integrate effectively into modern buildings and lifestyles.
Courtesy National Renewable Energy Laboratory
The Benefits of Thermal Mass
Well-designed thermal mass elements can provide a wide range of benefits, including:
- Lower Peak Loads. Storing heat in massive building elements contributes to lower peak loads, by allowing cool massive elements to soak up and then gradually release heat gains throughout the day. This reduces the diurnal fluctuation in temperature and results in more moderate heating and cooling spikes. Figure 1 provides a graphical representation of this effect on a summer day. The wintertime effect is similar.
Figure 1. Thermal Mass Moderates Interior Temperature Swings
Pacific Gas & Electric's commercial electric rates can include demand charges over $12 per kilowatt, and peak consumption charges up to twice as expensive as off-peak rates. During peak summer periods, Southern California Edison's demand charges can exceed $22/kW.
One University of California-Berkeley experiment in Palm Desert, California, involved pre-cooling thermal mass inside of a small bank building and monitoring energy and demand savings. Tests indicated a more than 30% reduction of peak air conditioner power and an average overall 0.76 W/ft2 reduction of peak power consumption.
If these demand savings were extrapolated throughout the year, the bank - a 12,000-square foot building - would save nearly $1,000 per year in demand charges alone! Of course, additional savings would be realized from the substantial reduction in energy consumption.
- Energy Savings. In addition to lowering peak loads, incorporating thermal mass into the building structure can contribute to savings in total space conditioning energy consumed year round. Thermal mass effects vary with climate, and a 2007 study entitled "Modeling Energy Performance of Concrete Buildings for LEED-NC v. 2.2, Energy and Atmosphere Credit 1" demonstrated an energy cost savings of 6 to 11% in a code-compliant concrete office building, as compared to a similar code-compliant steel office building simulated in several different climate zones.
- Thermal comfort. Proper application of thermal mass can delay heat flow through the envelope of a building by as much as 10 to 12 hours, providing a buffer against the weather during cold winters and hot summers. Additionally, thermal mass works well in commercial applications because it delays the peak summer cooling load - which generally occurs around 3 pm for buildings with less thermal mass - to later in the day when offices begin to close.
- Energy Demand Savings. Shifting the peak cooling load to later in the day can pay big dividends for a facility's energy bills, as demand charges may be avoided. In cases where demand charges are a significant component of the overall utility cost, the time of day that a building uses energy can be a major consideration. (See sidebar, On-Peak vs. Off-Peak Utility Costs.)
- Low Implementation Cost. Thermal mass is a relatively inexpensive, passive system that can be easily integrated into the building structure. Many buildings already incorporate concrete, bricks, and other massive elements. Designing for proper orientation and exposure of the building's mass elements can provide for significant energy savings with little increased building cost.
- Climate. Thermal mass is most appropriate in climates with a large diurnal temperature swing. As a rule of thumb:
- Diurnal ranges of less than 10°F are usually insufficient to provide significant savings potential.
- Ranges of 12 to 18°F can be useful, depending upon other factors, particularly humidity.
- Ranges of 18°F or more are well suited to massive construction. Exceptions to these rules occur in more extreme climates.
Figure 2 shows the summertime diurnal temperature range for selected California climate zones. Even in the more temperate Los Angeles and San Diego areas, diurnal temperature swings are sufficiently large that massing structures can make sense.
Figure 2. Diurnal Temperature Range for Selected California Climate Zones
- Implementation and Building Integration. Thermal mass can work to stabilize interior temperatures and minimize the need for active space conditioning, but a design that correctly links thermal mass to a heat source and air distribution system will improve the system performance.
Additionally, without a well-planned heating and cooling control strategy, the energy saving benefits of thermal mass construction may be negated. For example, employing a heating season setback can cause huge morning warm up demand spikes as the HVAC system must compensate for the overnight cooling of the massive elements.
- Type and Amount of Thermal Mass. Generally speaking, the thermal capacitance of a material is roughly related to its density. Water has more thermal mass than nearly any other material, but is not terribly practical as an architectural material. Brick, stone, earth, and concrete are certainly more common, and should be chosen based upon thermal capacitance, functional performance, appearance, and other factors. For example, high-density concrete provides more thermal mass than low-density concrete, and they can be used interchangeably in many applications. Regarding the amount of thermal mass to incorporate, beyond a 4-inch thick slab, diminishing returns begin to occur. For example, a 3-inch slab provides 95% of the performance of a 4 -in. slab.
Thermal Mass, Santa Monica Green Building Program
Thermal Mass, Concrete Thinking for a Sustainable World, Portland Cement Association, 2007
GreenSpec - The Low-Carbon House: Thermal Mass
Eco-tech: Critical Mass
Demand Shifting with Thermal Mass, PIER Demand Response Research Center
Design for Your Climate, Energy Design Resources
Strategies for Effectively Using Thermal Mass
The following tips and strategies can help to ensure that the massive elements in your building are successfully reaching their full energy-saving potential:
- Always use thermal mass in conjunction with good climate-adaptive design (see Design for Your Climate).
- Thermal mass works best when the massive elements are exposed on the interior surfaces of the building. Avoid covering important mass elements with carpet or other interior finishing elements. If using insulation, place it on the exterior side of thermal mass.
- The underside of floor slabs should be exposed to the occupied spaces. Avoid using suspended ceilings, which may form insulating barriers. Attempt to ensure "thermal transparency" in the ceiling if such a structure is required to provide a corridor for wiring, ductwork, or other connections. For example, consider using perforated or open-grid ceiling tile. Even 15% open area can allow for significant air circulation.
- Thermal mass works particularly well when coupled with natural ventilation systems (see e-News #61). For example, a night-flush cooling strategy introduces cooler exterior air into the building during nighttime hours to remove heat from massive elements.
- If possible, cool night breezes should be directed to flow over the thermal mass, flushing out all of the heat stored within the material. Night-flush ventilation can be improved by locating mass near diffusers, fans, or operable windows to facilitate removing heat.
- During the day, this mass should be sheltered from excess solar gains with shading and insulation.
- Thermal mass can be incorporated into lightweight structures through steel-framed concrete floors or isolated masonry walls. The underside and edges of suspended thermal mass floors that are exposed to the exterior should always be insulated, however.
- Internal or enclosed water features, such as fountains or pools, can also provide thermal mass, provided evaporation and condensation issues are carefully considered and controlled.
|Training & Event Highlights|
|California utilities offer outstanding educational opportunities that focus on the design, construction and operation of energy-efficient buildings. Listed here are a few of the many upcoming classes and events; for complete schedules, visit each utility's website.
Sustainable Building Envelopes
Low Energy HVAC Approaches for Nonresidential Buildings
Positive Net Energy Homes - The Passive House Concept
Balboa Park Sustainability Workshop Series 2009 - Green Building BasicsWhat makes a building "green"? This seminar answers the question by considering the five areas of the American Society of Heating, Refrigeration, and Air Conditioning (ASHRAE) Standard 189 and Leadership in Energy and Environmental Design (LEED). Both address 1) water efficiency; 2) energy efficiency; 3) sustainable sites; 4) materials and resources: and 5) indoor environmental quality. The workshop will discuss examples and impact on new construction and existing buildings, as well as the economics of green construction and retrofit. Offered June 18, 2009 in San Diego.
Don't miss future issues - to sign up for a free email subscription, please visit our
newsletter subscription page. Send letters to the editor, suggestions on topics for future
issues, or other comments to the e-News editor via our
Comments & Feedback form.
e-News is published by Energy Design Resources (www.energydesignresources.com), an online resource center for information on energy efficiency design practices in California.
Savings By Design (www.savingsbydesign.com) offers design assistance and incentives to design teams and building owners in California to encourage high-performance nonresidential building design and construction.
Energy Design Resources and Savings By Design are funded by California utility customers and administered by Pacific Gas and Electric Company, Sacramento Municipal Utility District, San Diego Gas and Electric, Southern California Edison and Southern California Gas Company, under the auspices of the California Public Utilities Commission.